What kind of India shall
we give to our children?
How to
reduce communal prejudice in our midst
A Short Guide to Secular Survival in India
What kind of India shall we give to our children? This is a question that every parent and right thinking person of India is asking today, in the midst of violence and communal hatred. Even if physical violence could be controlled by the police and the security forces, the communal prejudices in the minds of the people cannot be eliminated by force or punishment. It can only be reduced through constant interaction and trust-building measures between the communities. More so, how do we save our children - the decision makers of the future India - from imbibing prejudice or hatred based on communities or religions?
Here are some simple tips that may help you in the building of a tolerant and prejudice-free society for yourself and your children. These comments are not meant to criticize any particular community - they are meant for all peace-loving citizens of this country, but are against those who spread the hatred - whichever religion or creed they belong to. These are only suggestions - if you disagree with any of these ideas, please suggest alternatives, or tell us more measures like these. You can discuss these matters with your friends, family members, or children.
Being 'Secular' is not
being anti-religion
We have to make our children understand that being secular does
not mean being anti-religion or creating a new religious faith by
mixing two together. You can follow your own faith and yet
respect the faith and practices followed by others. Also, you
don't need to stick to only one kind of cultural identity - you
can have a dual or "multiple" cultural identity while
following your own religion. For example, as a Muslim you could
speak Tamil or any other language, or being a Hindu, you talk in
Arabic language - yet it won't affect your faith.
India belongs to many
communities
We have to understand that a land does not belong to any one
faith or community - it belongs to all who live there, whether
they are born there or have adopted it. So India, for example,
does not belong to the Hindu community alone. People of many
religions, tribes, and races, have been living here for thousands
of years. Many cultural influences such as the Islamic, the
central Asian and the European have enriched India's culture and
lifestyle. That is why our constitution defines India as a
secular state where people of all religions, customs, and castes,
have an equal right to live and profess their culture. And once
you consider a country yours, and are proud to be its citizen,
nobody should ask you to leave it or migrate elsewhere.
Seeds of prejudice at
home
We must realize that communal prejudices creep into a
child's mind at an early age. School teachers, friends, family
elders, and media -- all these can be potential channels of a
childs conditioning. The parents, therefore, must spend
some time and effort to check the growth of their children.
Observe them carefully as they grow, the way they behave, what
they talk, what kind of friends they make, and so on. Invite
their friends home and talk to them. Never discourage your child
to have friends from a different community. When elders are
talking in presence of children, make sure that the conversation
does not include your value judgments about any community or
caste.
Us and them
It is OK to tell your children about the cultural and
religious identity being followed in your family - whether you
are a Hindu or a Muslim. But whenever you make a distinction
between your culture and that of the other communities, tell your
child that all people and communities are equal in stature. There
maybe some differences because of geographic disparity, but no
culture or community is inferior or superior from any other. If a
child or adult tells you that the people of so-and-so community
are 'dirty' or 'crooked', ask them whether this opinion of theirs
is based on their first-hand experience or someone else's views.
If you observe a 'bad element' in any community, does that mean
that the entire community is like that? Can't both bad and good
elements be found in all cultures and communities? Try telling
them that all people wish to live peacefully - they sometimes
misbehave due to the conditioning or circumstances around them.
Why do you look like
that?
How do you or your children recognize the people of different
communities? Though many people in modern times no longer wear
the traditional garbs or looks such as beards, caps, turbans, or
burqas. However, some may still be recognized easily as Muslims,
Sikhs or Hindus. Your child may ask why do some people keep a
peculiar traditional outlook - "why are they different from
us?" One may explain as to how different geographic
conditions have made them look or behave differently. Tell your
child that she should not always expect to see people of a
certain community in dresses stereotyped to them. Very often our
television or cinema portrays the characters of a certain
community in their typical dresses, behaviours or accents, which
may not always be true. The teachers and parents should device
games and activities in which children from different communities
could be asked to spontaneously play the roles of the 'other'
community, in order to break the community typecasting in their
minds.
Can I wear your clothes?
Different communities may dress differently, but over
the years, many new dresses or styles have evolved in India out
of the synthesis of two or more different styles. The same could
apply to our adopting of different food habits, recipes, art,
languages, literature, music, or even architecture. In the
medieval times, as the historical evidences suggest, it was
sometimes difficult to differentiate between people of different
communities from their outlook - for instance most men in the
Mughal era wore turbans and kept beards. Even today, in some
rural or urban areas, you may find it difficult to tell a Hindu
lady from a Muslim one as most of them wear saris or salwar
suits. Since we live in a multicultural society, there is no harm
in adopting somebody else's dress code or even language if we
find it convenient, contemporary or comfortable. Sometimes the
geographic conditions may make it mandatory for everyone to
follow a certain cultural norm. For instance, in the coastal
region of India, everybody eats rice and fish, irrespective of
their religion or cast. Enlighten your child to such facts, e.g.
the Muslims of Kerala dress and eat differently from the Muslims
of Uttar Pradesh, or the Hindus of Assam have little in common
with the lifestyle of Hindus in Punjab, and so on.
Children need wide
exposure
If you live in a congested mohalla or a colony with all the
neighbours belonging to your community, you may feel comfortable
and cozy due to the neighbours, but dont assume that your
children too need the same. Give your child a wide-ranging
exposure to life. Take her to the houses or localities of the
people belonging to other communities and cultures, and also to
the prayer centres of all religions - mosques, temples,
gurudwaras, churches or others -- during their prayer times and
also when they are vacant. Expose her to books, films, music, and
television programmes, which portray a variety of cultures and
values. Try to travel with your child to as far away places as
possible, to give her a wide-ranging exposure. These suggestions
are not meant for the rich parents only -- such activities can be
carried out inexpensively, and must be considered by all right
thinking parents and teachers today.
Which school is best for
my child?
You should ideally select a school for your child that is known
for its secular and eclectic education, or where children of all
communities study. Though in reality, many parents end up sending
their kids to schools they are not quite happy with. Whatever be
the school, one should find out what kind of teachers it has, and
how they communicate with the children. If some teachers tend to
show community prejudices, the parents must meet them, or the
principal, to talk about this. Do they sing songs or prayers of
only one religion/culture in the morning assembly of your
childs school? In such a case, you can request the
principal to arrange for other type of songs/prayers too.
Interact with other parents, and organize parents' meeting to
discuss the quality of your childs education, and what you
could do to improve it. Remember that there is always scope for
educating your child at home if you are not happy or satisfied
with her school.
Are you a teacher?
If you are a teacher yourself, then you have a BIG
responsibility. If you have any general prejudice or hateful
feelings against the people of a particular community - which may
or may not reflect in your teaching - then you have no right to
remain a teacher. Never make fun or pass irresponsible remarks on
any community in the classroom or at home. Never try to curb or
ignore your pupils curiosity and inquisitiveness about
other cultures. Never give her wrong or unsatisfactory answers if
she has any questions about other communities. If you don't know
the answer then admit it frankly, and feel free to ask other
adults, or read up.
Reading textbooks,
history
The parents should look at, and critically evaluate, their
child's textbooks, especially about their representation of
different cultures, or historical facts. An appropriate reading
of history is a very important aspect of your childs
education. We must realize that due to our natural biases and
subjectivity, each of us can perceive and interpret a historical
event in a different way. It is impossible to write the
"most accurate" or perfect history of any place or era
as there is always room for different interpretations - sometimes
politically motivated interpretations. That is why conflicts
arise about so many historical events. The Partition of India,
for instance, is such a recent phenomenon that some people who
witnessed the events may still be alive - yet there are so many
conflicting versions of how the country got partitioned.
Why and how do we read
history?
So, while even a professional historian has tough time writing a
truthful history, what can we, as parents or teachers do? Well,
there is a lot we can. (1) We and our children should not read
history simply to know which king defeated who, but to learn the
examples of peaceful co-existence by our ancestors, and not to
repeat the mistakes they made. (2) We don't have to look into
history to settle past scores today - what has been done in the
past cannot be undone today. What you do today will be creating
new history and not taking a revenge for a 500 years old event.
(3) If you are unsure about the authenticity of a particular
historical event, check with a professional historian, and read
as many books/sources as you can. (4) Never read or quote a
passage or excerpt from a book in isolation or out of context.
(5) Remember that some historical source materials such as the
ancient books or inscriptions that we find today, were probably
written for the kings by their chroniclers, and therefore contain
history that the king wanted to be preserved, and may not
represent the complete reality of those times. It is comparable
to a press release issued by the government of the day about an
event that may not match entirely with a private newspapers
report.
History is one continuum
It is not appropriate to perceive our past by dividing it into
distinctive sections such as Hindu period, Muslim period or
Christian period. History is one vast continuum where many events
and trends overlap one another. One should avoid making value
judgments about various periods, such as labeling a particular
era as the golden period, while another one as the
dark age, and so on. Some people claim that their
traditional culture was most perfectly preserved till such and
such time in history, after which it started getting
polluted, as some outsiders brought in their own
cultures, and that today we need to go back to our original
culture. But historical evidences on the other hand tell us that
cultures have never remained fixed - they have been evolving and
changing all the time. Before the coming of Islam in India, for
instance, the Hindus of the Rig Veda period dressed, ate, and
spoke differently from those of the Mauryan period, who in turn
were somewhat dissimilar from the people of the Gupta period, and
so on. In all these eras, the society was also divided into
castes and sections, each having its own lifestyle and cultural
norms. Hence, it would be futile trying to find a particular era
in history that contains the most original culture of Hindus. The
same could be said about Muslims or other communities.
Was our past
destructive?
A lot of people stress that our history is full of invasions,
carnages, and injustice done by one community over the other.
Indeed, one can find instances of conquests and subjugation of
some people by others. But to blame any existing community or
people today for what their possible ancestors did yesterday
defies common sense and human values. The children should be told
that if there are instances of invasions and injustice in the
history, there are also thousands of examples of how people tried
to bridge the gap between communities, by spreading the message
of peace and human equality. Indian subcontinent has had hundreds
of sages, saints, and poets, who produced very simple but
impressive literature that talks of human equality, tolerance,
and divine love, besides criticizing wars, immorality and
religious dogmatism. This literature and poetry is as relevant
today as it may have been in their times, and needs to be
introduced to our younger generation.
Sending your child to a
religious school
Are you planning to send or have already sent your child to a
school that teaches only, or mostly, religious education? Maybe
you do not approve of the western influences and modernization in
life very much, or you may even be afraid that your traditional
culture is under threat from exposure to other cultures, and
therefore you want your child to get the traditional or religious
education. It is also possible that religious schools are cheaper
and you cannot afford a better school. In such a case, let your
child lead as normal a life as any progressive school student
would. Discuss with him whether this religious school or
institution is going to equip him/her to lead a progressive and
career-driven life, and how would he be able to adapt to the
demands of the modern-day life after graduating from a religious
school. If her school does not teach any modern subjects such as
natural sciences, social sciences, art and craft, mathematics or
English, then you must provide opportunities at home or at a part
time school where he/she can get the same. Encourage your child
to read books on a variety of subjects, besides what is taught at
the school. You can also discuss with the owner/principal of the
religious school to introduce modern subjects in school.
Encourage the child to have friends from other schools
make him visit a secular school to see the activities of other
kids there.
Is my religion better
than others?
There is nothing wrong in having a religious faith - as
long as you follow it peacefully, and allow others to follow
theirs peacefully. Study the tenants and history of your religion
properly you may also study other religions to understand
them better. But never try to make value judgments about
different religions before children -- don't make claims like
"our religion is the most perfect and relevant for all
mankind and all times, while others are not". Even a claim
such as "our religion has everything that is required for a
perfect life and we don't need to learn anything else from other
religions" sounds very arrogant, and should be avoided. In
fact, such claims are made by the followers of every religion,
with as much conviction as you would, so there is no point in
arguing endlessly on it. Tell your child that all religions have
evolved out of social needs - the founders of all religions
raised their voices against the corruption and decadence in their
respective society. Most religions have also gone through a lot
of dogmatism and ritualism in their practices, which may not
reflect the original message they started with. So one needs to
first understand the need for a religious faith before following
it.
Dont wear your
faith on your sleeves
Do you or your neighbours organize a lot of religious activities
at home or in the locality - Jagrans, special pujas, milads,
religious songs, shabads, religious speeches or azaan though
loudspeakers? As long as these remain within your house or up to
the houses of people who don't mind them, it is fine. But if any
of your neighbours get disturbed due to these activities or don't
like the noise at all, then you have to be careful. Always ask
your neighbours before organizing any such events. Never occupy
public utility spaces such as roads and footpaths, and minimize
the use of loudspeakers as much as possible. Think of the
students who might be studying, or small babies or sick persons
who are unable to rest due to the noise. Try to finish your
activities within the daytime dont disturb the
people with noise at night. If you want to take out a religious
procession on the road, always take permission from the police.
Restrict the procession to as small portion of the road as
possible, to avoid disruption of the traffic. Also keep it as
quiet and peaceful as possible, and finish it very quickly.
Our religious leaders
As part of your religious practice, you may be familiar with some
religious heads such as priests, imam, pundit or guru. Do they
understand the demands of today's life and give you a
contemporary interpretation of your religious belief, rather than
just reciting the old texts? Feel free to question them to clear
your doubts, rather than simply ingest whatever they preach. When
they pray for the benefit of people, do they remember only your
community, or do they pray for the entire humanity. Ask them to
pray for everyone and not just one community.
Celebrating together
In the past, one of the most popular ways of interaction between
different communities in India, was taking part in the
celebration of each other's festivals, and there are historical
evidences of that. Much of that spirit is now lost - it may be
hard to find Muslims celebrating Holi or Hindus rejoicing on Eid
in a spontaneous spirit. To begin with, you may encourage the
children to visit other friends' places who are celebrating their
festivals, and wish them. You may try to celebrate the 'others'
festivals inside your home by following some of their practices.
If you are a Hindu, you might like to cook siwain on the day of
Eid, or being a Muslim, try lighting up diyas (lamps) inside your
home on divali. But do these activities in a natural and
celebratory spirit involving the children throughout. Tell them
that they can participate in the festivals and cultural occasions
of the other religious communities and yet follow one's own
religion. Does your child's school organize some activities on
the festivals or cultural occasions of only one religion or
community? In that case, you may request the principal to observe
other festivals as well, even if the school has only one student
belonging to that religion. If the school is unable to organize
anything on your festival, then maybe the parent
could organize some activity, such as distributing sweets or a
gift to the principal or the teachers, or to the child's friends.
Respecting others
If you happen to be at a place where the people of the 'other'
community are busy in some prayer, ceremony, festivity, or a
procession, try to be in the same spirit as them - don't look at
them with scorn or disgust - be compassionate to their
activities. Basically give a message or vibe that you do not
disapprove of their activity, nor do you dislike them as a
community. You can even help them in an easy movement of their
procession or activity. But if you feel that their activities are
disrupting the traffic and disturbing or annoying you, then after
the procession, tell some responsible people of that community
that the next time they should be careful.
Intervene in the public
opinion
In public places like bus stands, trains, offices, religious
centres or other gatherings, people generally discuss violence
and communalism. If everyone in the group belongs to the same
community, their opinions tend to go against the 'other'
community. This is where much of public opinion is formed and
strengthened, as people share information, news, rumours, and
ideologies. If you are present in such public conversations, and
notice that an undue prejudice is being strengthened against a
particular community, you must intervene and try to present your
point of view. But assess the situation properly before jumping
in. To make your point convincingly you must have all your facts
clear and substantiated with references and documents. If someone
makes a discriminatory claim, ask him for reference or proofs.
During a conversation, if you feel that the things are going out
of hand and maybe violent, try to pacify the people. Do not get
agitated or raise your voice against the other person - don't put
them off. If you talk in a cool-headed and explanatory manner,
you'll have a better chance of being heard.
Who began it
all?
A typical argument put forward in such conversations is that
"they are the ones who started it first", referring to
the provocation by the 'other' community. This then leads to
allegations and counter allegations, going all the way back to
history. In such a situation, we must emphasize that it is
absolutely futile trying to find out who started it first. It is
a chicken-and-egg situation that will never find an end. Tell the
arguing people that most communal violence is the result of years
and years of hatred fed consciously or subconsciously into our
psyches. One may pinpoint an isolated case of violence or
provocation where somebody's mischief led to something larger.
But we cannot afford this unending chain of revenge any more -
somewhere we have to put an end to it. This is how one may try to
close the debate, or explain to the children. One must continue
to condemn all past acts of violence carried out by
whichever community.
Maintain peace in your
mohalla
Whether in peaceful or violent times, some responsible people of
a particular locality or colony (representing all communities)
must meet and decide that they will not let any communal violence
happen in their area. They can form a mohalla vigilance committee
to ensure safety of all the residents. If they find some
anti-social or violent elements, or a reason for discord in their
locality, it must be mutually resolved. The mohalla vigilance
committee should have the important tools of communication such
as telephone, mobile, Internet connection, and media resources
such as television, radio, and access to newspapers and
magazines, to remain abreast of the situation and to communicate
with the world outside, in case of an untoward event. Citizens
should also criticize the use of posters, banners and pamphlets
in their area. Besides dirtying the walls and roads, some
pamphlets or posters can carry provocative or potentially
dangerous messages. If you see anybody pasting or printing any
objectionable material, complain to the concerned authorities,
and tell as many people as possible, not to get swayed by the
provocative messages. If some important or essential message has
to be passed on to the public, fix up a certain area or wall in
your locality for these.
Passing through
their mohalla
Our towns and villages are composed of various types of
localities - some inhabited by only one community, while some
with a mixed population, some old and extremely congested
mohallas, while some wide-open and modern colonies - each
responding differently at the time of communal violence or
tension. The areas populated by only one community may be safe
and secure for that community during strife, but can also become
the haven for mobs planning or perpetrating violence. Such areas
can also prove to be a 'hell' for a single person of the 'other'
community passing by or getting stuck there during a communal
tension. If you get stuck in such a situation, think of a 'safe'
friend or acquaintance living nearby who could give you shelter.
Otherwise, keep walking with caution, and get out of the place as
soon as possible. On the other hand, if you reside in such an
area and notice somebody of the 'other' community walking down or
stuck during communal tension, you could help the person in
various ways. Give him/her shelter inside your place, take
him/her out of the locality safely, or let him make a phone call
from your house. If nothing, at least be nice to him, do not look
at him conspicuously, just go about your own chores, and do not
let others of your community trouble the person. Even in peaceful
times, a single person from a certain community - especially a
lady - passing by or standing in an alien area, being given
conspicuous looks by too many people, can make the person
extremely uncomfortable and even frightened.
Facing the
mob
What do you do if you are confronted by people who are known to
have committed an act of violence or 'terrorism'? If they are
agitated against 'your' community, and want to harm you, the
first thing would be to somehow inform the police, or anybody who
can help. If you don't have that choice, then try to politely
converse with them. If the situation is really out of your
control, the mob would do what they have to do; otherwise ask
them what are their problems, and is there any way they can
achieve their goals in a more peaceful way, or is there anything
of peaceful nature that you could do to reduce their problems.
Whatever way you can, try to persuade them to quit violence, or
at least direct their ire at those who are really responsible for
their problems, instead of you or other innocent people. Request
them especially not to harm children, women, the sick or old
people, animals, plants, religious places, schools, or hospitals,
or for that matter anything or anybody, as all religions are
against that.
Help in curbing violence
in your area
If someone from your family or neighbourhood exhorts you to come
out and do some 'equivalent' action against 'what the other
community has done', try to stop them politely from any such
action. Ask them where have they heard the news, and is it
confirmed? Always discourage any action of your family members or
neighbours that may lead to hostility in the area. If you are
unable to persuade the people, and see that things are going out
of hand, inform the police or some human rights groups
immediately. Try to make friends with other activists of peace
and human rights in your town, and keep their contact
numbers/address handy. You must also keep the numbers of
influential people such as the police commissioner, high court
judges, celebrities, journalists, and political leaders such as
MLAs or MPs. If you know any people in your area who have a
tendency to get violent at the slightest pretext, and may
perpetrate communal violence, keep a watch on them. If you
observe any of your neighbours or friends keeping a weapon,
firearms, or other dangerous items at home enquire from
them casually if they have the license to keep them, and why do
they own them. If they don't have a license for the weapons,
inform some human rights activists. Some people may tell you that
they keep the weapons for self-defense or security. But these
could also be used irresponsibly during a riot or violence.
Dealing with the Law
Help the police or authorities in their investigations or
combating of a violent or criminal activity. If the authorities
announce a special condition such a curfew or any other
prohibitory law in your area, do not violate it. If you have been
witness to something untoward in your area, remember all the
details, so that if you have to report to the police, you can
give them all the details. While reporting, insist on filing a
First Information Report (FIR), which is basically a detailed
written account on a plain paper, of what happened, addressed to
the Station House Officer of that police station or police post.
Do not change your account on your whim or anybody's pressure
honestly report what you have seen. Also, make sure that
the written report signed by you and accepted by the officer, is
not altered by anybody in front of you, and get a copy received.
If for some reason, the police or the authorities try to arrest
or detain you, ask them under which code or law are they
arresting you. If they have detained you without a warrant, they
have to produce you before the Magistrate within twenty-four
hours. In any case, you have the right to ask for a consul or
lawyer to defend you. If they want to enter your home for a
search, ask them if they have a search warrant.
You MUST help the victim
One unfortunate trait of the urban Indian society is a lack of
enterprise in helping people in desperate need or distress.
Besides large-scale tragedies where people do volunteer to help,
smaller accidents such as road mishaps are deliberately
overlooked by everyone. No one wants to get into the police
hassle - even if they know that the life of the bleeding person
lying on the road could be saved if they took him to the hospital
immediately. But WE DO NOT CARE - day after day. So who is at
fault - the police or the people? Surely the bureaucratic process
of the police investigation is such that the one who tries to
help can sometimes land into further trouble. But if you put
yourself in the place of the accident victim or his relatives,
you will surely blame the people who left the bleeding person
unattended. So whatever the situation, WE MUST HELP. The first
preference should be to take the victim to the nearest hospital.
If that is not possible, then at least call up the police or
medical help. If nothing else, at least try to bring the injured
victim to a more comfortable posture and location, try to stop
the bleeding and apply whatever first-aid measure you can. This
applies to all situations including communal violence, criminal
attack, road accidents, or natural disasters (God forbid if any
of these happen).
Is it news or rumour?
What do you do when the news of some communal violence comes on
TV, radio or newspapers? First thing - don't jump to any
conclusions until you get a clearer picture. Don't trust entirely
on what one channel or newspaper is telling you. If possible,
hear the news on different channels, radio stations, and papers.
Assume that there can be something more than what the media is
telling you. Never take any hurried actions based on the news you
hear. While discussing the news at home, workplace, or any public
place, never state anything more than the facts you know - even
little things said wrongly can deteriorate further and become
completely different rumours. Always try to curb the news that
sounds like a rumour. If your child brings some disturbing news
from outside, don't take it for granted. Ask the child where has
he/she heard it. What sorts of people were discussing it, and
what was their source of information. Tell the child not to trust
any news without confirming it.
How many humans
suffered?
In many of our homes, when the news of an accident or violence is
heard on television/radio, people start asking about the religion
of the victims or effected people - how many Muslims or how many
Hindus died? Most unfortunately, some people even express their
happiness or satisfaction if the people of the 'other' community
have died. This is a dangerous trend and can easily introduce
prejudices in the child's young mind. Whenever there is news of a
tragedy or riot, express your shock and grief - whatever be the
religion or community of the affected people. Even if your
children get curious about this, tell them that so many human
beings have been affected, not Hindus or Muslims. Give them a
sense of the pain and destruction that has occurred to so many
humans like them, and how futile all this violence is.
Understanding pain,
tolerance, non-violence
Many of our children's textbooks or some TV programmes praise the
virtues of non-violence and satyagraha without exploring the
human beings' natural tendencies towards anger, violence, and
pain. Anger and pain are natural emotions or reaction of the body
against unwarranted situations, just like love and affection are
for favourable situations. The parents or teachers could evolve
some activities or games in which children could get a real sense
of pain and violence; how these are stimulated and what is the
meaning of 'tolerance' in the real sense. Being tolerant does not
mean holding up our anger against someone. To be tolerant means
to accommodate the views that may differ from your opinion on a
given subject. The intolerance arises from insecurity, and the
insecurity of the masses is manipulated by politicians and vested
interests, to unleash violence in the society. To make our
children feel secure, we must make them recognize that just
because somebody's name or faith, or facial features, or colour
of skin is different, does not mean that they are conspiring
against us, or hate us.
Who are the
terrorists?
We are living under a constant threat of what are called the
'terrorist attacks'. How do we answer a child's queries about the
so-called 'terrorists'? While we must condemn the way these
groups mindlessly kill and maim innocent people and create scare
everywhere for their cause, we also need to go a little deeper to
find out what exactly is the motive of such people - what do they
achieve out of their acts of violence, and what is the history of
their struggle. We may realize that the so-called terrorists are
mostly misled young people whose emotions have been whipped up by
their leaders for political gains. Sometimes they have taken to
arms as a protest against long-term discrimination or persecution
by more powerful forces around them. However, there can certainly
be no excuse or justification for the killing or harming the
innocent people by anybody for any cause. Moreover, we must not
try to link a violent incident occurred somewhere, to a
particular community in some other part of the world. No scheme
of terrorism should be identified with any particular religion
(such as calling it Islamic terrorism or Hindu terrorism) just
because the persons involved in it are Muslims or Hindus. No
religion preaches terrorism or violence. Human life is too
precious to be destroyed for any purpose in the world. In fact,
anybody willing to sacrifice his life in the name of religion
does not know that committing suicide is one of the worst sins in
any religion.
Creating borders between
people
Some people take to arms, as they want to create a separate state
for themselves out of a larger country, on the basis of their
religious identity. But how can a land, where people of many
religions have lived together for hundreds of years, be divided
on the basis of only religious identity, especially if all the
people there have been following similar culture and language?
Havent we already learnt the futility of such efforts in
the past? If we have to create borders, then maybe the basis of
such a division could be culture or language, but not religion.
To give an analogy, a new state called Uttaranchal was recently
carved out of Uttar Pradesh in India, because of the unique
culture, language, and geography of that area. But during its
creation, no community in Uttaranchal needed to migrate
elsewhere, nor was anybody from outside asked to migrate to
Uttaranchal, even though Hindus, Muslims and other communities
live there. Hence, if we start respecting all cultures and
religions in our neighbourhood, there would be no need for
creating borders any more.
Television and Media
Television serials, movies and other modes of entertainment and
information that show some prejudice, or make fun of one
community -- even jokes that make fun of a community -- must be
discouraged. If you find a particular television programme
derogatory or unacceptable, you must make complaints about it to
the concerned authority. If you find something odd in newspapers
or magazines - prejudiced reporting or comments - you must
protest by writing to the editor. Carefully analyze the content
and the style of magazines, newspapers, and television channels,
to judge what editorial policies and ideologies they profess. If
you find anything doubtful or irresponsible in their content,
either complain to them, or look for a better newspaper or
channel. If possible, read more than one newspapers to get a
clearer picture. Make sure that your children read the right kind
of literature, or at least they are reading/watching things
critically. Try to shun any literature or television channels
that focus too much on patriotism, religious propaganda, and
mythical or superstitious folklore. When you don't want your
children to see television, think of some games and activities
you could do with them while the TV is off.
Inside your
office/workplace
In many offices and corporate houses, the white-collared workers
and executives are supposed to be educated and therefore
considered unbiased. While many people may genuinely be nice and
honest in their approach towards people of other communities,
some disturbing tendencies have also been noticed, mostly
concerning the relationship between the bosses and their
subordinates, if they belong to different communities. The boss
may give undue advantage to his juniors who share his religion or
community, or discriminate against his staff who belong to a
different community. On the other hand, the boss could be secular
and unbiased, but one of his/her subordinates (from a different
community) may mistake him/her to be otherwise, and qualify all
his/her actions to be based on communal prejudice. These are
sensitive issues, and many times even talking about them openly
may not be possible. Nevertheless, it is better to express your
feelings than hide them. Dialogue can always improve situations.
So if you start feeling extremely uncomfortable, you must break
the ice by openly talking about it. This applies not only to
offices but to similar situations in factories, shops, schools,
and other institutions as well.
Know your colleagues
Another common situation in the workplaces arises when a person
of a certain community wants to perform some prayer or other
activity related to his culture during office hours, but feels
uncomfortable, as many others find it odd. Often, the boss
doesn't allow the person to spend time for such activity during
office hours, or does not sanction a leave for a festival that
only this person wants to celebrate. In such a situation,
everyone, including the person in minority, the boss, and the
rest of the office, needs to have an open mind and some leniency
towards the work as well the religious activity. The best thing
would be to create an atmosphere of friendly sharing of
information about the cultures of each other. The person who
wants to perform the prayer or whatever, should tell everyone
what exactly he is doing. He may even invite everyone to join at
some point, for instance while breaking a daylong religious fast.
Similarly, a majority of people belonging to one religion
observing their festival or religious activity should make sure
not to intimidate one odd colleague of the other religion. If the
religiosity and the traditions have to be followed in a
workplace, then there should be acceptance of all religious
traditions with equal measure - and above all, no compromises
with your work or professionalism in the name of religion.
Shopping with a bias
While buying vegetables in the market, do you ever
wonder what the religion or caste of the shopkeeper is? India's
economy and markets are a complex network of manufacturers,
dealers, retailers, petty shopkeepers, and buyers, all belonging
to different communities and castes. Traditionally, in this
complex web, the people of different communities have played
their specific important roles. If one community is deliberately
marginalized by the others in the market, it will affect the
entire economy of that area and ultimately other areas. Never let
the religious identity of a shopkeeper, trader, or a client
affect your decision to do your business or shopping. Let only
quality and price be the factor for deciding where you buy your
things. Markets are the only places where people of all
communities, casts and races can join without any hang-ups or
taboos. Historically too, markets have provided platforms to
different cultures and languages to interact with each other and
evolve into newer cultures. They should continue to remain so.
Know your politician
Everyone agrees that the politicians of this country are taking
us for a ride, and are responsible for all that is going wrong.
But the question is, who elects them to power? We do. The system
of elections is the weakest aspect of our democracy. In every
election we are faced with the dilemma of who to vote for. Apart
from the individual claims and canvassing by the candidates and
political parties, there is unfortunately no system of knowing
who your candidate really is - what is his/her past record,
ideologies, vision and so on. Imagine when a big company recruits
a manager, the applicants have to go through very stringent tests
and interviews, and have to prove their worth through degrees and
experience certificates. And here we are - the owners of the
biggest and most prestigious company (India), recruiting our CEOs
without even knowing them or meeting them once. No wonder the
company is falling apart. Before you vote in the next election,
do try to find out as much information as you can about each
candidate standing in your constituency. Do not vote
irresponsibly.
Making democracy work
Besides choosing the right candidate, we must observe if
any irregularities take place in the election process - any body
being forced or allured to vote for a particular party, wrong
person voting for you, your name not being there in the voters
list, and so on. If you find any such problems, promptly report
to the authorities. If nobody listens, make a written complaint
to the election commissioner, or tell the representatives of the
candidates, or the media agencies. You must never miss a chance
to vote in any election. If you know someone who is not very keen
on exercising his voting right, request him/her to vote - this is
our most fundamental duty as a citizen of India. If we do not
vote, or vote irresponsibly, then we have no right to complain
about the government. After the elections are over and somebody
has won from your constituency, don't think your job is over. You
have to now keep an eye on what your elected leaders are up to.
Are they fulfilling their promises and duties? Are they doing
anything for their constituency and the people? Are they
representing you in the assembly or the parliament or not? If you
are not satisfied with their performance, complain to them -
better still, don't vote for them next time.
Participating in
corruption
Corruption is the root cause of many problems in this country,
and needs to be fought at every level. To begin with, we have to
check how much do we take part in the manifestation of corruption
ourselves. How many times have we broken a law (such as a traffic
regulation), and when confronted by an officer, have found an
easy way to escape by handing a currency note in is hands, rather
than pay the actual fine. How many times have we greased the
palms of a telephone repairman to get our faulty telephone
working? People become habitual of taking bribe only because we
pay them. And if we continue with such attitudes, we do not have
the right to complain about the corruption. We have to resolve
not to give bribe any more, whatever be the situation, and
however big or small be the amount. An officer with a tendency to
take bribe would make things very difficult for you if you don't
pay. But if you stick to your honesty, he/she would finally have
to budge. If corrupt officials realize that there is at least one
honest person around, they might think twice. If nothing, at
least you would feel great that you stuck to your stand. Do not
also indulge in any kind of nepotism, favouritism, or out-of-turn
work, nor let others do this sort of thing.
What makes you loyal to
your country?
Some people believe that to be called an Indian, you have to
prove your loyalty towards India, by doing certain activities
such as singing the national anthem or other patriotic songs, or
putting up the national flag on top of your house, and so on. Of
course we have to respect the national anthem and the flag, but
following these norms is not the only way of proving your
loyalty. To be loyal to India, you have to be loyal to your
fellow Indians -- whichever religion, caste, creed or status they
belong to. To be loyal to India, you must know the Indian
constitution and its laws, and abide by them. India is a
democratic socialist republic, but most of us do not know what
that means. If we knew our rights and duties as citizens of
India, we might be able to handle many day-to-day situations in a
responsible and judicious ways. We may even be able to fight
corruption and unlawful situations. Explain the real meaning of
democracy and fundamental human rights to your children. Also
train them to abide the laws and show responsibility in simple
matters of day-to-day life, such as not breaking queues or trying
to access something out of turn in a public place, defacing or
destroying public property, ticket-less traveling, stealing, and
so on. These would probably be better ways of testing ones
loyalty to the country than asking them to sing patriotic songs.
Fight for your rights
Do not fear the police, the armed forces, or the authorities.
They are there to help and safeguard the citizens. But if at any
point you feel that the police is not complying or helping you
the way they should, then bring it to the notice of human rights
groups, a court of law, or even the media. By law, even a
postcard sent to the court can be considered a public interested
litigation. If you have a grouse against the government in
general, you can file a case against it. You must raise your
voice against any injustice or violation of your human right,
carried out by any institution, office, shop, neighbour, or a
group of people. Do not blame your destiny or God for an
injustice. The children particularly should never be guided this
way. Encourage them to fight for their rights. But while doing
so, never take the law in your hands. Do not harm people or
property. Sometimes a silent protest can win you what a thousand
war cries may not. We have before us the examples of non-violent
struggles by Mahatma Gandhi and many others.
Yousuf Saeed
All rights reserved ©
Yousuf Saeed 2002
The help in the compilation of this booklet has come from many
friends. I would especially like to thank Surajit Sarkar, Vani
Subramaniam, Sadia Wahidi, Vagish Kumar Jha, Neelam Bhatt, Shobha
Aggarwal, and many others who have helped directly or indirectly.
We would like this booklet to reach more schools, teachers, and
parents. Please help us to spread this message to everyone, and
also suggest how we can improve it further.
To obtain print copies of the
booklet, please contact us through any of the following ways:
New Delhi telephone - 26988822, fax - 26822414
Emails: yousufsaeed@india.com or ysaeed7@yahoo.com
Website: http://www.cc-india.org http://www.alif-india.com